SAP Transport, Mobility & Society
SAP Transport, Mobility & Society

Children's independent mobility and school travel policies: convergences, divergences and open questions

Alejandra Esquivel de los Santos1 , Yeimys Judith Diaz Herrera2 , Jose Humberto Puente3
1Instituto Técnico en Ciencias Computacionales de Reynosa A.C., Reynosa, México
2Universidad de Cartagena, Colombia
3Universidad Pedagógica Experimental Libertador, Venezuela

https://doi.org/10.62486/tms2026350

PDF XML

Abstract

Children's independent mobility, the freedom to move about public space without adult accompaniment, has fallen across successive generations in many high-income countries, and the school journey has become a central site of policy intervention to reverse that decline. This narrative review weighs the empirical evidence on children's independent mobility and school travel policies, separating converging positions, contested positions and unresolved questions. The evidence converges on distance, child age and parental traffic-safety concern as the strongest correlates, and on modest but real associations of independent mobility and active travel with physical activity and well-being. It diverges on the effectiveness and equity of school travel policies, where evaluation designs and local implementation account for much of the disagreement. The review argues that restoring children's independence requires policies that address both the built environment and parental risk perceptions, and that equity must be measured rather than assumed.

Keywords

children's independent mobility, active school travel, walking to school, school travel policy, active transport, child health

INTRODUCTION

Children's independent mobility denotes the freedom a child has to move around their neighbourhood and city without an adult escort, whether on foot, by bicycle or by public transport.

Hillman et al.( 1) framed the construct in their study of English schoolchildren and tied it to a licence that parents grant children to use public space without supervision.

The concept matters because it links transport planning to child health and to the everyday autonomy of young people, and because it is routinely treated as a precondition for the physical activity, spatial knowledge and social competence children acquire as they grow.( 2,3)

One position dominates the field: independent mobility has collapsed, and the collapse is a public problem.

Hillman et al.( 1) reported that the share of seven- and eight-year-olds in England allowed to travel to school without an adult fell from 80 percent in 1971 to 9 percent in 1990.

Shaw et al.( 4) extended the comparison to Germany and to 2010, and their international comparison of 18,303 children aged 7 to 15 across sixteen countries concluded that low independent mobility is now the norm even where walking and cycling infrastructure is strong.( 5)

Kyttä et al.( 6) reached a similar verdict for Finland, a country long treated as an exception, and described the cohorts they surveyed as the last free-range children.

A second position qualifies that narrative. It holds that the decline is a rational parental response to motor traffic rather than a loss of nerve, so that restoring independence depends on engineering the road environment rather than on persuading parents to tolerate more risk.( 6,7)

Proponents of this reading point to the persistence of comparatively high independence in Finland, Japan and Denmark, where the decline has been slower than in English-speaking countries, and to the fact that children themselves describe traffic as the threat parents say it is.( 5)

The school journey has become the arena in which these positions collide, because it is the trip children make most often and the one governments can shape most directly. School travel policies, from Safe Routes to School infrastructure and walking school buses to school streets and school travel planning, promise to restore active and independent travel, but their evidence base is contested: evaluations disagree on whether the gains are real, durable and equitably distributed.( 8,9)

The stakes are not confined to transport, since the school trip carries much of the daily physical activity children obtain and much of the risk they face.( 3) The two sides of the debate read the same numbers differently: one sees a public health loss to be reversed, the other a safety gain to be defended, and both can point to evidence.( 2,10)

This review weighs the evidence for these positions rather than adjudicating them. Its aim is to identify where studies of children's independent mobility and school travel policies converge, where they diverge and why, and which questions remain open. Three questions guide the synthesis: how independent mobility and active school travel are conceptualized and measured; which determinants and outcomes are best supported; and what the evidence shows about the effectiveness and equity of school travel policies.

DEVELOPMENT

(Table 1) The five axes below set out the positions, the evidence and the questions that remain open, and Table 1 summarizes them. Findings are reported in the past tense as results of the cited studies, and each divergence is traced to the methodological reason that most plausibly explains it.

Table 1. Synthesis of the evidence by thematic axis.

Axis

Convergent evidence

Divergent or open questions

Representative studies

Concept, measurement and trends

A generational decline in CIM where it has been measured repeatedly, against a shared definitional core

The size and current level differ by country; no standardized instrument

Hillman et al. 1990; Shaw et al. 2013, 2015; Kyttä et al. 2015; Bates et al. 2015

Determinants

Distance, child age and parental traffic-safety concern are the strongest correlates

Objective versus perceived built environment; size and origin of the sex gap

Ikeda et al. 2018, 2019; Riazi et al. 2022; Marzi et al. 2018; Villanueva et al. 2013

Outcomes

Positive associations with physical activity, development and well-being

Magnitude and mechanism; reverse causation and dose

Schoeppe et al. 2013; Ferreira et al. 2024; Stark et al. 2018; Wu et al. 2025

Policies and interventions

Engineered safety raises walking and cycling and reduces pedestrian injury

Supervised schemes show modest effects; durability and equity uncertain

McDonald et al. 2013; Buttazzoni et al. 2018; Johnson et al. 2024; Patterson et al. 2025

Equity and context

Disadvantage and disability are under-served

The socioeconomic gradient changes sign across contexts; voices rarely counted

Carver et al. 2014; Ross et al. 2018; Pojani and Boussauw 2014; Medeiros et al. 2021

Concept, measurement and temporal trends

Studies converge on a definitional core. Independent mobility is measured as the licence children have to move without adult supervision, whether as a set of permissions, as destination access or as the share of unsupervised trips.( 11)

Bhosale et al.( 12) compared interactive mapping with destination access and licence scales in 219 children and found that the instruments correlated but captured different parts of the construct. T

he temporal finding is equally consistent: in the countries with repeated measurement, independent mobility declined across the twentieth century and has not recovered.( 4,6)

Lidbe et al.( 13) reported the same direction in United States school travel mode choices over recent decades, with the car share rising as walking declined.

The instruments behind these series differ enough to matter. Kyttä et al.( 6) used a set of licences covering travel to school, leisure destinations and play, a scheme that treats independence as graded permission rather than a single threshold.

Destination-access measures count where a child may go, interactive mapping captures where they went, and licence scales record what parents say they would allow.( 11)

Bhosale et al.( 12) found these three only moderately correlated, which explains why studies using different instruments reach different absolute levels of independence for the same city, and why Sharmin and Kamruzzaman( 14) argue for a trip-based ratio that is less dependent on parental wording.

Where studies diverge is on the size and current level of the decline.

Shaw et al.( 5) placed Finland, Germany, Norway, Sweden, Japan and Denmark well above France, Israel, Sri Lanka, Brazil, Ireland, Australia, Portugal, Italy and South Africa, a spread they attributed to differences in car dominance and in national tolerance for traffic risk rather than to climate or wealth.

Carver et al.( 7) likewise found lower independence in Australia than in England despite similar urban forms, which they read as evidence that cultural permission, not the built environment alone, sets the ceiling. This reading holds that the decline is a policy choice rather than a law of development.

The persistence of high independence in Japan, where young children make short solo trips to school from the first primary years, and in the Nordic countries, where winter does not suppress walking, supports the view that the ceiling is set by social norms and car restraint rather than by infrastructure alone.( 5,6)

The trend data also invite a cohort interpretation. Each cross-section that reports a decline compares different children, and the licence a parent grants a seven-year-old is shaped by the mobility that parent had at the same age.( 4)

The comparative studies capture this only partly, because they ask about the child's licence, not about the parent's, so the transmission of the decline across generations remains inferred rather than measured.( 6)

The generational question matters for policy, because a norm that is handed down cannot be reversed by a single infrastructure grant, and the countries that have slowed the decline are those that acted on both the street and the social norm at once.( 5)

The measurement problem cuts across both positions. Parent-reported licences confound permission with practice, and destination access ignores the quality and meaning of the journey.( 11)

Sharmin and Kamruzzaman( 14) proposed the proportion of independent to dependent trips as a measure sensitive to the built environment, but it has not been validated across settings. The temporal series rest mostly on parent report, so part of the measured decline could reflect changing reporting norms rather than changing behaviour. Until a shared instrument is adopted, the field will keep reporting country differences that are partly artefacts of method.( 11)

Determinants of independent mobility and active school travel

Across designs, distance stands out as the strongest and most robust correlate of active and independent school travel, followed by child age and by parental concern about traffic.( 15,16)

Mehdizadeh et al.( 17) quantified walking time to school and confirmed that distance sets a hard constraint on mode choice, while Chillón et al.( 18) showed that distance and parental barriers operate together in United States samples.

Kent et al.( 19) reviewed the distances and durations of active school travel and showed that the threshold at which walking and cycling collapse is tight, which turns school siting and catchment policy into de facto mobility policy.

The meta-analysis of New Zealand children by Ikeda et al.( 20) estimated built-environment associations from individual participant data, and their structural equation models indicated that household and individual factors act partly through parental attitudes.( 21)

Riazi et al.( 22) replicated the age and neighbourhood pattern in a Canadian multi-site study, and Buliung et al.( 23) found the same gradient in Toronto.

Studies part company on the weight of the objective built environment relative to the perceived one.

Villanueva et al.( 24) reported that neighbourhood walkability predicted independent mobility after adjusting for parental, sociocultural and individual factors, whereas Helbich et al.( 25) found in a Dutch GPS study that natural and built exposures predicted active school travel only weakly once distance and household characteristics were held constant.

The divergence is methodological rather than substantive: the Melbourne estimate relies on self-reported licences, the Dutch one on objectively recorded routes, and the two quantify different things. Ozbil et al.( 26) came closer to reconciling the positions by modelling perceived and objective street measures together, and Lopes et al.( 27) attributed the urban-rural gradient in Portugal to motorized modes rather than to distance alone. A meta-analytic review by Sharmin and Kamruzzaman (28) found built-environment associations for independent mobility that were real but small, a result consistent with the idea that the environment acts through parental permission.

The social environment sits between these positions. Wolfe and McDonald( 29) attributed independent mobility to parental perceptions of neighbours rather than to built form, and Pacilli et al.( 30) tied independence in Italian children to their participation in public space.

Wilson et al.( 31,32) reported from participatory mapping that children weigh sociality and nature alongside traffic, a view that surveys of parents understate.

Parental support appears to be a distinct lever: Mah et al.( 33) found that support predicted active school travel after accounting for household characteristics, and van den Berg et al.( 34) linked parental safety perception and satisfaction to the mood children carried into school. Norms act as a further layer, since school travel mode choice is partly explained by environmental norms and parental transport priorities.( 35,36)

The direction of these associations remains open, because permission and behaviour plausibly reinforce each other and the longitudinal designs that would separate them are absent from these samples.( 37,38)

Household resources set the floor beneath these gradients. Car availability, parental work schedules and the number of children compete with the child's age for influence, and the age at which parents grant the licence varies more across cultures than within them.( 16,23)

Two children of the same age in the same neighbourhood can therefore hold different independence because their households run different trip chains, a pattern that aggregate models of the built environment capture only indirectly.( 39)

The licence itself deserves treatment as an outcome rather than only as a mediator. Studies that measure permission separately from behaviour find that the two move together but are not the same thing, and that permission responds to neighbourhood features even when behaviour does not.( 11,38)

Framing the licence as the target clarifies why two households with identical built environments reach different decisions, and it aligns the measurement agenda of the field with the outcome that parents actually control.( 12)

Sex differences are reported almost universally, with boys granted more independence than girls, but their size and origin are contested.

Marzi et al.( 40) reviewed the correlates separately by sex and gender and could not attribute the gap to a single environmental driver, while Ghekiere et al.( 41) found that the socio-ecological correlates of independent cycling differed between boys and girls.

This reading cautions against treating gender as a control variable rather than as a mechanism, and against universal policies that ignore how girls and boys use streets differently.( 42)

The built environment and sociodemographic characteristics also combine unevenly across children, so aggregate models explain less than they appear to.( 39)

Health, developmental and safety outcomes

The outcome literature is the most convergent part of the field. The systematic review by Schoeppe et al.( 3) concluded that children's independent mobility and active travel were positively associated with physical activity and, less consistently, with lower sedentary time and healthier weight status.

A later systematic review extended the benefit beyond energy expenditure to autonomy itself, linking independent mobility to cognitive and socio-emotional development.( 43)

Longitudinal and quasi-experimental evidence supports the well-being reading: Stark et al.( 44) reported better attitudes and psychological well-being among active school travellers, Ramanathan et al.( 45) documented positive emotion during the journey itself, and Wu et al.( 46) estimated a causal effect of active school travel on children's subjective well-being from a Chinese panel.

The developmental evidence points in the same direction. Ferreira et al.( 43) concluded that autonomy itself, rather than movement alone, predicted better cognitive and socio-emotional outcomes, and Stark et al.( 44) found that the psychological benefit attached to the journey rather than to the destination.

These findings locate the value of independent mobility in what children gain by finding their way alone, not only in the energy they expend, and they imply that a policy that swaps an active accompanied trip for a sedentary independent one would miss part of the benefit.

The disagreement concerns magnitude and mechanism. Weight-status associations are weak and inconsistent across studies, and Schoeppe et al.( 3) themselves flagged the scarcity of intervention studies as the reason causal claims were premature.

Martin et al.( 47) qualified the well-being benefit: perceived neighbourhood safety moderated the association, so that active travel improved health-related quality of life only where children felt safe. Time of day adds a further condition, since independent mobility falls sharply during dark hours and the evidence on evening travel is thin.( 48)

What remains open is reverse causation and dose. Children who are already fitter and more confident may be the ones granted independence, and no study has established how much unsupervised travel is enough to matter for health. The well-being estimates are also vulnerable to the same measurement problem that affects the exposure side of the field, because independence, active travel and the outcomes are self-reported in the same instrument in many of these studies.

The safety question cuts both ways. The very traffic exposure that makes parents withhold independence is also the exposure that active travel policies seek to manage, and the studies reviewed treat the two as separate questions rather than as one trade.( 47)

Independent mobility also varies across the day: the scoping review by Litsmark et al.( 48) documented how sharply the licence contracts during dark hours, which means that a child judged independent in a summer questionnaire is not independent in the winter school run that the same instrument would capture.

The school trip is also a question of dose. Active school travel can contribute a substantial share of recommended daily physical activity, and parental support for the trip is one of the few modifiable determinants with consistent evidence.( 3,33)

Even so, the dose depends on distance and duration, which are short for most children, so the journey alone cannot carry the whole activity burden and the health case rests on autonomy as much as on energy expenditure.( 19,43)

School travel policies and interventions

(Table 2) Policy positions converge on the mechanism, which is to make the school journey safer and more attractive, but they diverge on the size of the effect. Table 2 lists the main instruments and the state of their evidence.

Table 2. School travel policies and interventions, their stated mechanism and the state of evidence.

Policy instrument

Stated position or mechanism

Evidence status

Representative studies

Safe Routes to School and engineered safety

Safer crossings and lower vehicle speeds raise walking and cycling and reduce injury

Convergent, mostly quasi-experimental

McDonald et al. 2013; DiMaggio et al. 2013

School travel planning

Mobilize school and community resources to shift car trips to active modes

Convergent for mode shift, modest effect

Mammen et al. 2013, 2014; Buttazzoni et al. 2019

Walking school bus

Adult-supervised group walking to raise activity and safety

Divergent; small gains and volunteer dependence

Turner et al. 2013; Johnson et al. 2024

School streets and traffic restriction

Close or restrict vehicle access at the school gate

Promising but inconclusive; durability and equity open

Aliyas et al. 2026; Patterson et al. 2025; Alliott et al. 2026

School walkability audit

Score routes and schools to prioritize investment

Convergent as a planning tool

Lee et al. 2020

The strongest convergent result comes from engineered safety. The Oregon evaluation by McDonald et al. found that Safe Routes to School infrastructure and non-infrastructure investments raised walking and cycling among treated schools,( 49) and a separate analysis showed the programme was associated with lower school-aged pedestrian injury.( 10)

School travel planning, the Canadian and Australian model, is associated with a shift from car to active travel in several before-after cohorts,( 50,51) and its influence appears to run through school policies and practices as much as through infrastructure.( 52)

Buttazzoni et al.( 53) reported a comparable regional pattern in elementary schools, and school-level walkability audits formalize the same logic by scoring routes and schools for intervention priority.( 54)

Supervised schemes such as the walking school bus tell a more qualified story. Turner et al.( 55) found that walking school bus programmes were rare in United States elementary schools, which limits their reach, and a cluster randomized controlled trial detected only modest increases in physical activity that depended on sustained adult volunteers.( 56)

Buttazzoni et al.( 8) reviewed North American intervention methodologies and attributed the mixed results to weak designs and short follow-up rather than to failure of the instruments themselves, and their qualitative account of a regional Safe Routes to School programme identified implementation capacity as the binding constraint.( 57)

An umbrella review of the correlates and interventions reached the same conclusion.( 9)

The instruments do not substitute for one another. School travel planning changes the journey through engagement and low-cost fixes, engineered safety changes the road, and school streets change the space at the gate, and each reaches a different population.

The global programme reviews conclude that combined approaches outperform single instruments, and that the children least likely to benefit are those whose schools lack the staff and parent capacity that even the cheapest instruments require.( 57,58)

This is a reach problem as much as an effectiveness problem, and it is why the school street, which requires no volunteer roster, has spread faster than the walking school bus it partly replaces.( 59,60)

The evaluation record is constrained by the way programmes are selected for study. Schools that adopt Safe Routes to School or travel planning are self-selected, so before-after gains confound the intervention with the motivation of the schools that sought it, and spillovers to neighbouring schools dilute the comparison groups.( 8,53)

The controlled and randomized designs that avoid these threats are newer and fewer, so the convergent and divergent findings on policy currently rest on different kinds of evidence and cannot yet be resolved by weighting one against the other.( 56,61)

School streets and traffic restriction schemes are the fastest-growing instrument, and their evidence is still forming. Canadian School Street studies link the closures to more independent mobility and active travel,( 59) and a controlled natural experiment measured the effectiveness and equity impacts of restriction schemes outside schools.( 61)

Alliott et al.( 62) identified the mechanisms, which include reduced vehicle speed at the gate and a changed parental calculus, and Rutberg et al.( 63) showed that children themselves request the changes these schemes deliver.

Durability once novelty fades remains open, as does the question of whether the gains reach the children with the least independence.( 60,61)

The global programme reviews agree that effectiveness depends on implementation context more than on the instrument chosen.( 19,58)

The equity question is now explicit in the strongest designs: Patterson et al.( 61) measured equity impacts alongside effectiveness, and their controlled natural experiment is the template the field has been missing, because it separates who benefits from how much the average child benefits.

Equity and context

The equity axis converges on a gap between who needs active travel and who receives it.

Children in disadvantaged areas have lower independent mobility and territorial range in Australian and Canadian samples,( 22,64) and disability is systematically under-treated in both the active school travel and the independent mobility literatures.( 65)

A scoping review of ableism in school transportation reached the same conclusion for school systems.( 66)

Parents in disadvantaged neighbourhoods frame the same trip in terms of risk that wealthier families report as routine, which shapes their willingness to allow independent travel.( 67)

The direction of the socioeconomic gradient, however, is not universal. In Tirana, Pojani and Boussauw( 68) documented high active school travel that persisted largely because car ownership was low, and Latin American surveys show high active commuting alongside income-related differences in escorting.( 69)

patial analyses in Mexico City link escorting to active travel in ways that invert the high-income pattern,( 70) and adolescent public transport use follows its own set of constraints.( 71)

This contrasts with the English-speaking pattern and indicates that active travel can signal constraint as much as freedom.( 72)

Cross-national equivalence compounds the difficulty. The instruments developed in Europe and North America assume a child who may walk or cycle, and they do not map onto cities where the dominant independent mode is public transport or where the school trip is negotiated collectively.(71) The equity claims estimated in high-income settings therefore cannot yet be transferred to the lower-income cities where active travel is highest,(68,69) and the field has no shared yardstick for deciding whether a child in Tirana and a child in Toronto hold the same independence.

The voices that are counted form a further divide. Children and adolescents describe the school journey in terms of sociality and belonging that parents report as risk,( 73,74) and culturally safe options are a precondition for meaningful participation in some communities.( 75)

The review of gender, socioeconomic and ethnic reporting in intervention studies concluded that most programmes neither measure nor report equity,( 76) which means the field can currently say little about who benefits.

Closing that gap would require collecting the same equity variables across studies, a change that is procedural rather than costly, and it would let the effectiveness and equity questions be answered from the same designs instead of from separate literatures.

DISCUSSION

A synthesis premised on the strongest version of the decline narrative would predict that independent mobility fell everywhere, that no policy restores it, and that the outcome evidence is too weak to justify action.

The assembled literature supports a more qualified position. Independent mobility has fallen in the countries that measure it repeatedly, but the level and pace vary widely, and the decline tracks car dominance and traffic risk more than climate or wealth.( 5,6)

The outcome associations are modest, yet they are consistent across designs and include a quasi-experimental estimate for well-being,( 46) which is more than the strongest version of the sceptical position concedes.

The divergences in this literature are mostly methodological, and naming the method that produces each one is more useful than appealing to context. The gap between objective and perceived built environment rests on measurement: self-reported licences behave differently from GPS-recorded routes, and each is being asked to stand for independence.( 24,25)

The gap on policy effectiveness rests on design: programmes evaluated with before-after cohorts report gains, while randomized and controlled designs find smaller effects, and short follow-up hides decay.( 8,56)

This reading of the field implies that the next generation of evidence should measure the built environment and the licence together, and should evaluate policy with designs that can detect equity, not only average effect.( 61,76)

The synthesis also reorders the field's priorities. Determinants of the licence, and especially parental traffic-safety concern, explain more of the variation than most single built-environment variables, which suggests that policy must move both levers at once.( 15,16)

This contrasts with earlier reviews that treated the built environment as the primary target,( 2) and it aligns with the newer finding that school streets work partly by changing the parental calculus rather than the asphalt alone.( 59,62)

Where the earlier reviews and this one agree is on measurement: without a shared instrument, cross-national comparison will keep producing apparent divergences that are artefacts of method.( 5,11)

Read across the axes, the equity findings are the least settled and the most consequential. The same design that makes a school street effective also determines whether its benefits reach the children who already hold the least independence, and the natural experiments now measuring that question remain the exception rather than the rule.( 61,76)

The socioeconomic gradient changes sign across contexts, so equity cannot be imported from one setting to another: a policy that raises active travel in a car-dependent suburb may be irrelevant in a city where walking is already the default and the binding constraint is safety rather than access.( 64,68)

The classic evaluations read differently when placed beside the newer designs. The walking school bus studies that reported activity and pedestrian-safety gains were small and often volunteer-led,( 77,78) and the early school travel planning literature documented mobilization rather than durable mode shift.( 79)

These are not failures: they are what the instrument can achieve under the conditions that made the pilots possible.

The cluster trial that followed found the ceiling those conditions impose,( 56) and structural instruments that change the road, not the roster of volunteers, now attract the field's attention for that reason. State-level laws that codify Safe Routes to School priorities operate on the same logic, by embedding the programme in policy rather than in individual schools.( 80)

The road-safety framing deserves more weight than either camp gives it. The decline of independent mobility coincided with large reductions in child road casualties, and the parental concern that drives the decline is a response to a real hazard concentrated on the routes to school rather than an irrational anxiety.( 10,34)

Treating the decline as a loss of nerve misreads that evidence, while celebrating the casualty reductions as an unqualified gain obscures that they were bought partly by confining children indoors. A policy that lowers speed at the school gate attacks both sides of this trade at once, which is the mechanism the school street exploits.( 59,62)

The three bodies of evidence connect through a single causal chain. Parental risk perception, built by traffic exposure and social norms, sets the licence; the licence sets how much children move and what they learn while moving; and policy acts on the first link of that chain, either by lowering the exposure through engineering or by reshaping the norm through school-level culture.( 15,29,43)

The interventions that appear most effective are those that strike the first link, and the school street has advanced while exhortations to walk have not.( 56,59)

For practice, the review supports three implications. First, school travel policy should be judged on whether it increases the licence, not only the mode share, because the health and developmental benefits attach to autonomy rather than to walking alone.( 3,43)

Second, interventions that rely on adult volunteers have a built-in ceiling, and their modest average effects in trials should be read as a call for structural alternatives such as school streets and traffic restriction.( 56,61)

Third, equity must be measured as an outcome, because the socioeconomic gradient changes sign across contexts and cannot be assumed.( 64,68)

For practice, this translates into a short list of moves that are defensible on the current evidence. School siting and catchment policy should treat distance as a mobility decision, since the threshold at which walking collapses is known and tight.( 19) Speed management at the gate should precede or accompany any behavioural campaign, because it addresses the parental calculus that the built-environment and social-environment literatures both identify as decisive.( 15,29)

And every new school street or traffic restriction should be instrumented to report who benefits, by income and disability, so that the equity question stops being a limitation and becomes a measured outcome.( 61,76)

The field needs a validated instrument that separates permission, practice and destination access, longitudinal designs that identify the direction of the health associations, and policy evaluations that report equity and durability by design.

The most tractable next step is to attach those measurements to the school street and traffic restriction programmes now expanding, so that the instrument being scaled is evaluated at the moment of scaling. The same instrumentation would deliver the dose-response and equity estimates the field lacks, and it would turn the next generation of school travel policy into a testable proposition rather than a hope.

CONCLUSIONS

Children's independent mobility has declined where it has been measured repeatedly, but the decline is uneven and tracks traffic risk more than any fixed law of development. The evidence converges on distance, child age and parental traffic-safety concern as the dominant determinants, and on modest but consistent associations of independence and active travel with physical activity and well-being.

School travel policies diverge in their measured effects, and the divergence is explained by evaluation design and implementation rather than by a failure of the instruments themselves. The licence to move without supervision, not the mode share alone, is the outcome that policy should target, and equity must be measured rather than assumed if the school journey is to become more than a daily negotiation between risk and autonomy. What the evidence offers is not a single answer but a sharper question: how to rebuild the licence to move for the children who have lost it, without asking their parents to trade safety for it.

References

  1. 1 Hillman M, Adams J, Whitelegg J. One False Move: A Study of Children's Independent Mobility [Internet]. Policy Studies Institute; 1990. Available from: https://trid.trb.org/view/339888
  2. 2 Marzi I, Reimers AK. Children’s Independent Mobility: Current Knowledge, Future Directions, and Public Health Implications. IJERPH. 2018;15(11):2441. doi: 10.3390/ijerph15112441
  3. 3 Schoeppe S, Duncan MJ, Badland H, Oliver M, Curtis C. Associations of children's independent mobility and active travel with physical activity, sedentary behaviour and weight status: A systematic review. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport. 2013;16(4):312-319. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2012.11.001
  4. 4 Shaw B, Fagan-Watson B, Frauendienst B, Redecker A, Jones T, Hillman M. Children's independent mobility: a comparative study in England and Germany (1971-2010) [Internet]. 2013. Available from: https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:89103856-a239-489a-8e7e-b6c1bad43a0f
  5. 5 Shaw B, Bicket M, Elliott B, Fagan-Watson B, Mocca E, Hillman M. Children's Independent Mobility: an international comparison and recommendations for action [Internet]. 2015. Available from: https://archive.org/details/ChildrensIndependentMobility
  6. 6 Kyttä M, Hirvonen J, Rudner J, Pirjola I, Laatikainen T. The last free-range children? Children’s independent mobility in Finland in the 1990s and 2010s. Journal of Transport Geography. 2015;47:1-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2015.07.004
  7. 7 Carver A, Watson B, Shaw B, Hillman M. A comparison study of children's independent mobility in England and Australia. Children's Geographies. 2013;11(4):461-475. doi: 10.1080/14733285.2013.812303
  8. 8 Buttazzoni AN, Van Kesteren ES, Shah TI, Gilliland JA. Active School Travel Intervention Methodologies in North America: A Systematic Review. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. 2018;55(1):115-124. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2018.04.007
  9. 9 Zeng E, Hino K, Chen Y, He N. Toward sustainable active school travel: A systematic umbrella review highlighting correlates and interventions. Cities. 2026;175:107177. doi: 10.1016/j.cities.2026.107177
  10. 10 DiMaggio C, Li G. Effectiveness of a Safe Routes to School Program in Preventing School-Aged Pedestrian Injury. Pediatrics. 2013;131(2):290-296. doi: 10.1542/peds.2012-2182
  11. 11 Bates B, Stone MR. Measures of outdoor play and independent mobility in children and youth: A methodological review. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport. 2015;18(5):545-552. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2014.07.006
  12. 12 Bhosale J, Duncan S, Stewart T, Chaix B, Kestens Y, Schofield G. Measuring children's independent mobility: comparing interactive mapping with destination access and licence to roam. Children's Geographies. 2017;15(6):678-689. doi: 10.1080/14733285.2017.1293232
  13. 13 Lidbe A, Li X, Adanu EK, Nambisan S, Jones S. Exploratory analysis of recent trends in school travel mode choices in the U.S. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives. 2020;6:100146. doi: 10.1016/j.trip.2020.100146
  14. 14 Sharmin S, Kamruzzaman M, Haque MM. The proportion of independent to dependent trips: A new measure to understand the effects of the built environment on children independent mobility. Journal of Transport & Health. 2021;22:101127. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2021.101127
  15. 15 Ikeda E, Hinckson E, Witten K, Smith M. Associations of children's active school travel with perceptions of the physical environment and characteristics of the social environment: A systematic review. Health & Place. 2018;54:118-131. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2018.09.009
  16. 16 Riazi NA, Wunderlich K, Yun L, Paterson DC, Faulkner G. Social-Ecological Correlates of Children’s Independent Mobility: A Systematic Review. IJERPH. 2022;19(3):1604. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19031604
  17. 17 Mehdizadeh M, Mamdoohi A, Nordfjaern T. Walking time to school, children's active school travel and their related factors. Journal of Transport & Health. 2017;6:313-326. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2017.01.012
  18. 18 Chillón P, Hales D, Vaughn A, Gizlice Z, Ni A, Ward DS. A cross-sectional study of demographic, environmental and parental barriers to active school travel among children in the United States. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2014;11(1):61. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-11-61
  19. 19 Kent JL, Hossein Rashidi L, Moylan E, Owen K, Crane M, Militão AM, et al. A Systematic review of active school travel distances and durations. Transport Reviews. 2026;46(5):890-905. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2026.2647794
  20. 20 Ikeda E, Stewart T, Garrett N, Egli V, Mandic S, Hosking J, et al. Built environment associates of active school travel in New Zealand children and youth: A systematic meta-analysis using individual participant data. Journal of Transport & Health. 2018;9:117-131. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2018.04.007
  21. 21 Ikeda E, Hinckson E, Witten K, Smith M. Assessment of direct and indirect associations between children active school travel and environmental, household and child factors using structural equation modelling. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2019;16(1):32. doi: 10.1186/s12966-019-0794-5
  22. 22 Riazi NA, Blanchette S, Trudeau F, Larouche R, Tremblay MS, Faulkner G. Correlates of Children’s Independent Mobility in Canada: A Multi-Site Study. IJERPH. 2019;16(16):2862. doi: 10.3390/ijerph16162862
  23. 23 Buliung RN, Larsen K, Faulkner G, Ross T. Children’s independent mobility in the City of Toronto, Canada. Travel Behaviour and Society. 2017;9:58-69. doi: 10.1016/j.tbs.2017.06.001
  24. 24 Villanueva K, Giles-Corti B, Bulsara M, Trapp G, Timperio A, McCormack G, et al. Does the walkability of neighbourhoods affect children's independent mobility, independent of parental, socio-cultural and individual factors?. Children's Geographies. 2014;12(4):393-411. doi: 10.1080/14733285.2013.812311
  25. 25 Helbich M, Emmichoven MJZV, Dijst MJ, Kwan MP, Pierik FH, Vries SID. Natural and built environmental exposures on children's active school travel: A Dutch global positioning system-based cross-sectional study. Health & Place. 2016;39:101-109. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2016.03.003
  26. 26 Ozbil A, Yesiltepe D, Argin G, Rybarczyk G. Children’s Active School Travel: Examining the Combined Perceived and Objective Built-Environment Factors from Space Syntax. IJERPH. 2021;18(1):286. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18010286
  27. 27 Lopes F, Cordovil R, Neto C. Children’s independent mobility in Portugal: effects of urbanization degree and motorized modes of travel. Journal of Transport Geography. 2014;41:210-219. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2014.10.002
  28. 28 Sharmin S, Kamruzzaman M. Association between the built environment and children's independent mobility: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Transport Geography. 2017;61:104-117. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2017.04.004
  29. 29 Wolfe MK, McDonald NC. Association Between Neighborhood Social Environment and Children’s Independent Mobility. Journal of Physical Activity and Health. 2016;13(9):970-979. doi: 10.1123/jpah.2015-0662
  30. 30 Pacilli MG, Giovannelli I, Prezza M, Augimeri ML. Children and the public realm: antecedents and consequences of independent mobility in a group of 11–13-year-old Italian children. Children's Geographies. 2013;11(4):377-393. doi: 10.1080/14733285.2013.812277
  31. 31 Wilson K, Clark AF, Gilliland JA. Understanding child and parent perceptions of barriers influencing children’s active school travel. BMC Public Health. 2018;18(1):1053. doi: 10.1186/s12889-018-5874-y
  32. 32 Wilson K, Coen SE, Piaskoski A, Gilliland JA. Children's perspectives on neighbourhood barriers and enablers to active school travel: A participatory mapping study. Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes. 2019;63(1):112-128. doi: 10.1111/cag.12488
  33. 33 Mah SK, Nettlefold L, Macdonald HM, Winters M, Race D, Voss C, et al. Does parental support influence children's active school travel?. Preventive Medicine Reports. 2017;6:346-351. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2017.04.008
  34. 34 van den Berg P, Waygood EOD, van de Craats I, Kemperman A. Factors affecting parental safety perception, satisfaction with school travel and mood in primary school children in the Netherlands. Journal of Transport & Health. 2020;16:100837. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2020.100837
  35. 35 Mehdizadeh M, Nordfjaern T, Mamdoohi A. Environmental norms and sustainable transport mode choice on children’s school travels: The norm-activation theory. International Journal of Sustainable Transportation. 2020;14(2):137-149. doi: 10.1080/15568318.2018.1532542
  36. 36 Mehdizadeh M, Fallah Zavareh M, Nordfjaern T. School travel mode use: direct and indirect effects through parental attitudes and transport priorities. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science. 2019;15(2):749-775. doi: 10.1080/23249935.2018.1529838
  37. 37 De Meester F, Van Dyck D, De Bourdeaudhuij I, Cardon G. Parental perceived neighborhood attributes: associations with active transport and physical activity among 10–12 year old children and the mediating role of independent mobility. BMC Public Health. 2014;14(1):631. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-631
  38. 38 Mitra R, Faulkner GE, Buliung RN, Stone MR. Do parental perceptions of the neighbourhood environment influence children’s independent mobility? Evidence from Toronto, Canada. Urban Studies. 2014;51(16):3401-3419. doi: 10.1177/0042098013519140
  39. 39 Li M, Wang Y, Zhou D. Effects of the built environment and sociodemographic characteristics on Children's school travel. Transport Policy. 2023;134:191-202. doi: 10.1016/j.tranpol.2023.02.018
  40. 40 Marzi I, Demetriou Y, Reimers AK. Social and physical environmental correlates of independent mobility in children: a systematic review taking sex/gender differences into account. Int J Health Geogr. 2018;17(1):24. doi: 10.1186/s12942-018-0145-9
  41. 41 Ghekiere A, Deforche B, Carver A, Mertens L, de Geus B, Clarys P, et al. Insights into children’s independent mobility for transportation cycling—Which socio-ecological factors matter?. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport. 2017;20(3):267-272. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2016.08.002
  42. 42 Egli V, Mackay L, Jelleyman C, Ikeda E, Hopkins S, Smith M. Social relationships, nature, and traffic: findings from a child-centred approach to measuring active school travel route perceptions. Children's Geographies. 2020;18(6):667-683. doi: 10.1080/14733285.2019.1685074
  43. 43 Ferreira IA, Fornara F, Pinna V, Manca A, Guicciardi M. Autonomy as key to healthy psychological well-being: A systematic literature review on children's independent mobility, cognitive and socio-emotional development. Journal of Transport & Health. 2024;38:101837. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2024.101837
  44. 44 Stark J, Meschik M, Singleton PA, Schützhofer B. Active school travel, attitudes and psychological well-being of children. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour. 2018;56:453-465. doi: 10.1016/j.trf.2018.05.007
  45. 45 Ramanathan S, O'Brien C, Faulkner G, Stone M. Happiness in Motion: Emotions, Well‐Being, and Active School Travel. Journal of School Health. 2014;84(8):516-523. doi: 10.1111/josh.12172
  46. 46 Wu L, Qin Z, Jing P, Xue Y, Shao D, Luo P. The Causal Effect of Active School Travel on Children’s Subjective Well-Being: Evidence from the China Family Panel Survey. J Happiness Stud. 2025;26(6):109. doi: 10.1007/s10902-025-00947-8
  47. 47 Martin G, Graat M, Medeiros A, Clark AF, Button BLG, Ferguson KN, et al. Perceived neighbourhood safety moderates the relationship between active school travel and health-related quality of life. Health & Place. 2021;70:102623. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2021.102623
  48. 48 Litsmark A, Rahm J, Mattsson P, Johansson M. Children's independent mobility during dark hours: a scoping review. Front Public Health. 2023;11:1110224. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1110224
  49. 49 McDonald NC, Yang Y, Abbott SM, Bullock AN. Impact of the Safe Routes to School program on walking and biking: Eugene, Oregon study. Transport Policy. 2013;29:243-248. doi: 10.1016/j.tranpol.2013.06.007
  50. 50 Mammen G, Stone MR, Faulkner G, Ramanathan S, Buliung R, O’Brien C, et al. Active school travel: An evaluation of the Canadian school travel planning intervention. Preventive Medicine. 2014;60:55-59. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2013.12.008
  51. 51 Mammen G, Stone MR, Buliung R, Faulkner G. School travel planning in Canada: Identifying child, family, and school-level characteristics associated with travel mode shift from driving to active school travel. Journal of Transport & Health. 2014;1(4):288-294. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2014.09.004
  52. 52 Ikeda E, Mavoa S, Cavadino A, Carroll P, Hinckson E, Witten K, et al. Keeping kids safe for active travel to school: A mixed method examination of school policies and practices and children’s school travel behaviour. Travel Behaviour and Society. 2020;21:57-68. doi: 10.1016/j.tbs.2020.05.008
  53. 53 Buttazzoni AN, Clark AF, Seabrook JA, Gilliland JA. Promoting active school travel in elementary schools: A regional case study of the school travel planning intervention. Journal of Transport & Health. 2019;12:206-219. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2019.01.007
  54. 54 Lee S, Lee C, Nam JW, Abbey-Lambertz M, Mendoza JA. School walkability index: Application of environmental audit tool and GIS. Journal of Transport & Health. 2020;18:100880. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2020.100880
  55. 55 Turner L, Chriqui JF, Chaloupka FJ. Walking School Bus Programs in U.S. Public Elementary Schools. Journal of Physical Activity and Health. 2013;10(5):641-645. doi: 10.1123/jpah.10.5.641
  56. 56 Johnson AM, Zhou C, Haviland M, Mendoza JA. Evaluation of a walking school bus program: a cluster randomized controlled trial. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2024;21(1):55. doi: 10.1186/s12966-024-01602-w
  57. 57 Buttazzoni AN, Coen SE, Gilliland JA. Supporting active school travel: A qualitative analysis of implementing a regional safe routes to school program. Social Science & Medicine. 2018;212:181-190. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.07.032
  58. 58 Zhang X, Ma L. Fostering Sustainable School Journeys: Insights from Global Active School Travel Programs. Journal of Planning Literature. 2026;41(1):50-67. doi: 10.1177/08854122251322448
  59. 59 Aliyas Z, Thompson C, Bakkali F, Collins PA, Frohlich KL. Reclaiming urban space for children: Examining the impact of School Streets on independent mobility and active transport. Can J Public Health. 2026;117(1):140-150. doi: 10.17269/s41997-025-01058-w
  60. 60 Thompson CM, Collins PA, Frohlich KL. Promoting children’s health through community-led street interventions: analyzing sustained voluntarism in Canadian School Streets. BMC Public Health. 2024;24(1):1011. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-18531-9
  61. 61 Patterson R, Carey EG, Garrott K, Huang Y, Ogilvie D, Hadfield-Hill S, et al. Effectiveness and equity impacts of traffic restriction schemes outside schools: a controlled natural experimental study. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2025;23(1):19. doi: 10.1186/s12966-025-01858-w
  62. 62 Alliott O, Guell C, Ogilvie D, Hadfield-Hill S, Panter J. Exploring how traffic restriction schemes outside schools influence the school journey: a qualitative analysis of mechanisms and contextual factors. BMC Public Health. 2026;26(1):2988. doi: 10.1186/s12889-026-28386-x
  63. 63 Rutberg S, Henriksson M, Andersson M, Palstam A, Lindqvist AK. My Way to School Through a Camera Lens: Involving Children to Inform a Policy Recommendation on Active School Travel. Health Promotion Practice. 2025;26(3):437-445. doi: 10.1177/15248399241255376
  64. 64 Carver A, Veitch J, Sahlqvist S, Crawford D, Hume C. Active transport, independent mobility and territorial range among children residing in disadvantaged areas. Journal of Transport & Health. 2014;1(4):267-273. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2014.01.004
  65. 65 Ross T, Buliung R. A systematic review of disability’s treatment in the active school travel and children’s independent mobility literatures. Transport Reviews. 2018;38(3):349-371. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2017.1340358
  66. 66 Comeau É, Chan A, Buliung R, Lewis I, Ross T. Understanding the manifestations and impacts of ableism in school transportation: a scoping review. Transport Reviews. 2025;45(4):514-536. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2025.2486002
  67. 67 Nyström M, Henriksson M, Lindqvist AK, Rutberg S. Making the right decision for our children's future: Parents' perceptions of active school travel in disadvantaged neighborhoods. Journal of Transport & Health. 2023;30:101617. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2023.101617
  68. 68 Pojani D, Boussauw K. Keep the children walking: active school travel in Tirana, Albania. Journal of Transport Geography. 2014;38:55-65. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2014.05.012
  69. 69 da Silva JI, de Souza Andrade AC, Muraro AP. Global Physical Activity, Active Commuting to School, and Sedentary Behavior Among Latin American Adolescents: Global School-Based Student Health Survey and the National School Health Survey. Journal of Physical Activity and Health. 2024;21(9):879-889. doi: 10.1123/jpah.2022-0645
  70. 70 Bautista-Hernández DA. Spatial patterns and determinants of children's school travel mode choice in México City: The link between escorting and active travel. Journal of Transport & Health. 2026;48:102270. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2026.102270
  71. 71 Jafari M, Delbosc A, Currie G. Factors influencing independent travel of pre-driving adolescents through public transport: a systematic literature review. Transport Reviews. 2025;45(5):726-748. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2025.2504020
  72. 72 Loh V, Sahlqvist S, Veitch J, Walsh A, Cerin E, Salmon J, et al. Active travel, public transport and the built environment in youth: Interactions with perceived safety, distance to school, age and gender. Journal of Transport & Health. 2024;38:101895. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2024.101895
  73. 73 Morris S, Lawlor ER, Foley L, Summerbell C, Panter J, Adams J, et al. Children's experiences of the journey between home and school: A qualitative synthesis using meta-ethnography. Health & Place. 2022;76:102819. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2022.102819
  74. 74 Legorburu I, Idoiaga Mondragon N, Alonso I, Berasategi N. Why are you allowed to go to school on your own? Exploring children's voices on independent mobility. Children & Society. 2022;36(6):1111-1125. doi: 10.1111/chso.12559
  75. 75 Waipapa Taumata Rau/University of Auckland, Mihaere S, Smith M, Jones R. THE IMPORTANCE OF CULTURALLY SAFE ACTIVE SCHOOL TRAVEL OPTIONS TO ENABLE TAMARIKI MĀORI TO FLOURISH A narrative review and model. MAI Journal. 2024;13(1):26-38. doi: 10.20507/maijournal.2024.13.1.3
  76. 76 Medeiros A, Buttazzoni A, Coen SE, Clark AF, Wilson K, Gilliland J. Review of gender, socioeconomic status, and ethnic background considerations reported in active school travel intervention studies. Journal of Transport & Health. 2021;21:101035. doi: 10.1016/j.jth.2021.101035
  77. 77 Sayers SP, LeMaster JW, Thomas IM, Petroski GF, Ge B. A Walking School Bus Program. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. 2012;43(5):S384-S389. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2012.07.009
  78. 78 Mendoza JA, Watson K, Chen TA, Baranowski T, Nicklas TA, Uscanga DK, et al. Impact of a pilot walking school bus intervention on children's pedestrian safety behaviors: A pilot study. Health & Place. 2012;18(1):24-30. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2011.07.004
  79. 79 Buliung R, Faulkner G, Beesley T, Kennedy J. School Travel Planning: Mobilizing School and Community Resources to Encourage Active School Transportation. Journal of School Health. 2011;81(11):704-712. doi: 10.1111/j.1746-1561.2011.00647.x
  80. 80 Chriqui JF, Taber DR, Slater SJ, Turner L, Lowrey KM, Chaloupka FJ. The impact of state safe routes to school-related laws on active travel to school policies and practices in U.S. elementary schools. Health & Place. 2012;18(1):8-15. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2011.08.006

Declarations

Funding

No financing

Conflict of interest

None

Authorship contributions

Drafting – original draft: Alejandra Esquivel de los Santos, Yeimys Judith Diaz Herrera, Jose Humberto Puente.

Writing–review and editing: Alejandra Esquivel de los Santos, Yeimys Judith Diaz Herrera, Jose Humberto Puente.

Citation copied